A multi-physics Eulerian framework for long-term contrail evolution (MultiCon): Single plume analysis
Abstract. Condensation trails (contrails) evolve from formation and rapid growth to dissipation or transition into cirrus clouds (i.e., the long-term diffusion regime), where the latter phase largely determines their radiative forcing. This research develops a high-speed Eulerian contrail plume solver for large-scale analyses while approximating the multi-physical processes governing plume evolution. We propose a unified Eulerian framework for the long-term regime of contrails that integrates the population balance equation with ice-particle growth dynamics. Under suitable assumptions, the governing nonlinear field equations admit dimensional separability, allowing the horizontal and vertical evolution to be nearly decoupled. Consequently, the plume microphysics is described by a highly nonlinear system of ((z,t)) partial differential equations (PDEs), while the horizontal evolution governs plume spreading. Since this work considers single-plume analysis, we focus mainly on the coupled vertical PDE system, extending existing large-scale contrail models from tracking bulk quantities to resolving the plume's spatiotemporal evolution. The PDEs incorporate several underexplored factors, including multiphase behavior of the bulk settling velocity of ice particles in turbulent flows, a parameterization of ice-crystal habit dynamics that modifies growth, sublimation, and settling, as well as stochastic diffusion and vertical wind. The model also introduces adjustable parameters that can be calibrated using ground-truth data to optimize the nonlinear PDEs. Owing to its computational speed (roughly below 1 second to simulate 10 hours of plume evolution), the solver is well suited for large-scale simulations of contrail evolution and radiative forcing. Notably, although the mathematical framework is general capable of resolving/approximating polydispersity, the current solver assumes a monodisperse distribution.
This paper propose a new framework for simplified contrail simulation in its diffusion phase. This model is able to solve habit evolution of ice crystals and bulk settling velocity. This model is describe in detail and I congratulate the authors on the clarity of their explanations. It is then applied in 2D (z,t) and a sensitivity study has been made to numerical parameters (time step, discretization in z) and physical parameters. Finally a 3D (x,z,t) simulation has been made to compared the new model to CoCiP, the most used model for this kind of simulation by the community.
I find the idea used by the authors to developed a complete multiphysic eulerian-eulerian framework and then simplified the system with several assumption leading to very low computational time very interesting. I think most of the approximations are good, however I regret in the writing that little order of magnitude are given to justify them. It also lack of comparison with other model, there is one with CoCiP in one case, but there is results from APCEMM and CoCiP available in the literature as well as 2D LES results. It should have been great to have more comparison with other model.
In conclusion, I think this paper is interesting and deserve to be published. However, I think some part deserve more detail. In the supplement there is more detailed remarks.